HomeEditorial teamTo Map Is To Murder

To Map Is To Murder

The Trivialisation of Cartography and Its Grave Implications

Maps to geography are like diagrams to economics, like equations to mathematics. They’re an invaluable tool for representing complex topics in a digestible format, but if you’ve spent any time studying or engaging with mapmaking, you’ll understand that maps aren’t representations; they’re arguments.

Maps are cherry-picked amalgamations of details and information that the mapper chose to highlight, at the cost of all others, to convey a message with a specific purpose. However, the much less discussed truth about mapping concerns the political decision that the vast majority of cartographers make: Maps are perpetuations of political hegemony.

When you disseminate any information about societal organisation or material reality using a representative model, you make an unavoidable sacrifice. With a limited canvas of two-dimensional space, only so much knowledge can be included. Given that maps exist to communicate specific knowledge in a specific way, they inevitably sideline the human experience and abstractify the dynamics at play.

‘Playing Risk’ by Tambako The Jaguar – Flickr

One illustrative example of this abstraction is the popular board game Risk, where players fight for control of territories on a world map in an attempt to come out on top and capture the whole board using a simple set of military pieces. Although superficially harmless, through its contribution to the cultural normalisation of violent conquest and imperialism — responsible for an inconceivable amount of murder, torture, suffering, rape, and exploitation throughout history — it reduces the material implications of all this pain to a colourful puzzle, even as a casual outlet during a night at the pub, after which all players walk out of the room with a strengthened understanding that war is a distant concept of no significant concern to them.

The takeaway here isn’t that we need to cancel a board game, but rather that we need a collective reflection on the atrocities we strip of their context, trivialise for entertainment, and treat like a game. By not reminding people of the reality of fiction, we collectively lose the reality of truth. Risk, if designed well, could be a lesson; an exploration of the horrors of war and what accumulating plots of colour truly looks like in practice.

The popular retort to this is that humans aren’t emotionally capable of grappling with constant reminders about the horrors of human existence and need safe spaces from evil in order to live a healthy life. This is largely inarguable, given the popularity of escapist fiction and our tendency to turn a blind eye to the plethora of problems our civilisation is riddled with. However, if people actively contribute to evil on a daily basis, is actively broaching it not a moral obligation?

You are in a geography class. The professor assigns you a project to map land-use patterns in the Netherlands. At first, this may seem like an innocent opportunity for students to hone their mapping skills, get acquainted with relevant software, refine their visual communication skills, and perhaps even learn something about their immediate environment. While all these lessons are true, the greatest lesson is never taught: What do we mean by ‘land use’? Who is using it? Who are the winners? Who are the losers? Who decides these? How? Why?

Beyond the bigger picture, there are minutiae you will trivialise. The legend in this map by Statistics Netherlands contains a green-beige rectangle to mark agricultural land use. What agriculture? What does that entail? I’ll give you a hint: Mass abuse and systematic murder of farm animals in torturous conditions. Every passing day these conditions continue, yet you turn a blind eye and fail to speak up, instead of choosing to reduce the horrific exploitation of animals, biodiversity, and our local environment to a shade of green on your .jpeg file and go on with your day. Surely you must ask yourself: What did I really map?

You are a wartime reporter at the BBC. You have been tasked to visualise missile strikes in the 2026 Iran War. Congratulations, by doing so, you have just reduced an incomprehensible number of lost lives, dreams, aspirations, and horrors beyond our imagination to a collection of red dots. By abstracting human suffering to situation briefings using deliberate language and mapping choices, you have denied your audience the right to view the imagery and consequences of these strikes, and effectively reduced death and destruction to a distant game of Risk.

Human beings are neurologically hardwired to fail at conceptualising large-scale terror. By choosing to map a geographic element of the conflict, you’ve made yet another critical decision by opting for maps as the graphical medium. Who are you reporting it to and why? Wouldn’t available video or photographic evidence of the schools and homes being decimated report the conflict much more accurately? Whose interests are you serving by creating this map for an article that will be algorithmically placed above more raw, graphical coverage of the war, assuming your employer distributes that in the first place?

You are an editorial writer at your faculty magazine. You seek to highlight examples of brutal injustices cartography trivialises on a daily basis in order to bring the vital nuances of mapping to your readers’ attention. You choose the victims of animal agriculture and the casualties of war in Iran. Congratulations, you have thoroughly abandoned the victims of an ongoing genocide you are afraid to name in an article published under your full name due to potential consequences from academic, employment, and border authorities you’ll encounter later in life. Yet the aforementioned issue is only one among others barely rewarded to us in the Western media zeitgeist. Comprehensiveness eludes us all.

There is a level of journalistic self-awareness required to map ethically. Simplification, representation, visualisation… These are the gladiatorial hunger games of knowledge curation. To mention is a deliberate decision not to mention. The attention economy is a zero-sum game — and attention rules the world.

Every choice is an omission, so choose carefully. The world is a complex, interdependent web of organisms, realities, and wicked problems. As a cartographer, you are playing with fire in the metaphorical oil field that is science and journalism, hence recognition of the power you wield is critical, because its susceptibility to wrongdoing is infinite.

That is the inevitable opportunity cost of cartography. It applies to all knowledge, really, but as the messengers of space, the output of cartographers is not only consequential, but a matter of life and death, because no matter what, to map is to lie. To map is not to map. To not map is to abandon. To depict is to exclude. To visualise is to hide. To hide is to sentence. To map is to murder.

Elliot Crozier
Elliot Crozier
Hey there! I'm Elliot, an undergraduate student in Human Geography and Planning and a former Chief Editor of our lovely magazine. I love all things big-picture and international, with a particular interest in the human condition, politics, philosophy, culture, geography, urbanism, and cartography, all of which I'm excited to bring to the table! :)
RELATED ARTICLES